I have bought a lot of notebooks. I mean this as a confession, not a boast. For years I read the guides the way you'd read a spec sheet for a washing machine — forty features, five paper types, a comparison table long enough to scroll past twice — and I still ended up standing in a shop, or hovering over a checkout, no closer to knowing what I actually wanted. The guides never helped because they were answering a question I didn't have. I didn't need to know everything a notebook could be. I needed to know which one I'd still be writing in come March.
So here is the shorter version, the one I wish someone had handed me before the drawer filled up. To my mind a notebook that earns a place on the desk needs three things, and everything past them is preference wearing the costume of a decision. It has to open flat. The paper has to hold ink without bleeding. And A5 is the size that works. That's the whole list. I've tested the rest the expensive way.
The one I kept coming back to, in the end, wasn't the handsome one with the debossed cover I'd been so pleased with. It was a plainer book that simply stayed open on its own while I wrote, so that my left hand was free and my train of thought didn't keep breaking to flatten a page. I didn't notice why I preferred it for a long time. I just noticed I reached for it, morning after morning, until it was full and soft at the corners and unmistakably mine.
It has to open flat
A notebook that fights you shut is a notebook you quietly stop using. You don't decide to abandon it; you just find it a little less inviting each day until one morning your hand reaches past it. The thing that makes a book lie still and open is the binding, and I've learned to feel for it. What I look for is a sewn book — Smyth-sewn or Singer-sewn, the pages stitched together in signatures rather than glued in a slab at the spine. A glued notebook cracks along its back after a few weeks and then springs itself closed the moment my hand lifts. A sewn one relaxes. It settles into the desk, holds the gutter open, and lets me write right into the centre of the page without pinning it down like a specimen. That isn't a luxury detail. It's the difference between a book I fill and a book I baby.
The paper has to hold the ink
My test is simple and slightly obsessive: I turn a page and press a thumb to the back of what I've just written. If the words are shadowing through, or worse, if the nib has feathered and spread the way ink does on cheap stock, then it's really only half a notebook — because I'll only ever trust one side of each sheet. Good paper takes a fountain pen, a gel pen and a fineliner in turn and gives all three a clean, unbroken line, and it does it without ceremony. This is less about the brand printed on the cover than about weight and finish: a smooth, appropriately heavy sheet feels honest under the nib, the way a well-made desk feels honest under your forearms, and it doesn't let the writing print itself onto the next page down.
A5 is the size that works
Big enough to think on, small enough to carry — that's the whole case for A5, and I've come to think it's the quietly correct answer for almost everyone. It gives a full page to spread an idea across without the book becoming a thing you leave at home because it won't fit the bag. It sits on a crowded desk without demanding the desk be cleared for it. Most people arrive at A5 the same way I did, which is to say by trying everything else first — the pocket books that ran out of room mid-thought, the grand A4 volumes that never left the shelf — and then landing, a little sheepishly, on the size that had been the sensible choice all along.
A word on the spine you can see
You'll sometimes find notebooks with the stitching left exposed along the back, the signatures showing like the spine of a small hardback. It looks like a design flourish and it isn't one. Those visible threads are the whole reason the book opens flat and stays bound through years of being carried, dropped, and shoved into bags. A notebook built this way — the mishmash journals we stock are the example nearest to hand, Portuguese, Smyth-sewn, flat from the very first page — tends to outlive three or four of the glued books I'd otherwise have bought and quietly binned in the same span of time.
So I buy for the binding, not the cover. The cover is what you admire for a second under the shop lights. The binding is what you actually live with, every morning, for a year.
Opens flat, holds its ink, A5. Anything that fails those three, I leave on the shelf now — and I haven't stood paralysed in a stationery aisle since.
What's the one notebook you keep coming back to — and have you ever stopped to work out why?
If you'd like more of this — plain tools, chosen slowly and carefully — the newsletter goes out to people who'd rather own one good thing than ten passable ones. Sign up here.